Trapped in the wet soil, he see the burning bush as well as God, who appears in the form of a young boy. By Justin Chang. An early battle scene against the Hittites, modeled very closely on the climactic battle scene between Arabs and Turks in Lawrence of Arabia, suggests that Moses is the superior warrior, which prepares for his eventual banishment once Ramses succeeds his father on the throne. [30] The Red Sea scene was filmed at a beach on Fuerteventura, one of the Canary Islands off the northwest coast of Africa. He wants people -- both Israelites and Egyptians -- to understand his uniqueness, his compassion and love, as well as his justice. Finally, it must be noted that "Exodus: Gods and Kings" is exceedingly depressing in tone. He takes this as the explanation for his visions, but the ending of the movie reveals the truth goes even deeper. This tortured family drama was performed much more persuasively in Gladiator by Russell Crowe, Joaquin Phoenixand Richard Harris. Upon Moses threatening Ramesses's life, Ramesses orders Moses's death, as well as killing random Hebrew families until Moses is found. [9] Christian Bale said of Moses, whom he portrayed, "I think the man was likely schizophrenic and was one of the most barbaric individuals that I ever read about in my life. [57] Audiences surveyed by CinemaScore gave the film a grade "B" on scale of A to F.[58], Stephen Farber of The Hollywood Reporter gave a positive review and said, "Scott did a great job reviving the Roman sand-and-sandals epic when he made the Oscar-winning Gladiator. Additional comment actions In their (very limited) defense, some older games like Metro: Exodus, Rise (?) In director Terrence Malick's Knight of Cups (2015), . The Bible: Exodus is a story of ethical and political redemption. [31] There were 400,000 humans depicted in total, with 30 to 40 people accompanying Bale while crossing the Red Sea and the rest being computer generated. [7], Some controversy and criticism arose concerning biblical accuracy of the script and its portrayal. He talks to Malak again, who tells him that if he truly believes in what he's writing, that he ought to continue.The Hebrews make their way through Mount Sinai. Exodus: Gods and Kings grossed $65 million in the U.S. and Canada and $203 million in other territories for a worldwide total of $268.2 million. Seti then switches them, telling the young men to fight to save the other's life in battle. Moses survives and rejoins the Hebrews. [47] In its third week, the film added $30.9 million from 39 markets and was still halted at number two behind The Battle of the Five Armies. Moses returns home where soon after Seti dies, and Ramesses becomes the new Pharaoh (Ramesses II). Exodus 23:27 When you fight you Or "News of my power will go before you, and your enemies will be frightened." The film portrays both Seti and Ramses in a slightlymore positive light. [53] They praised its acting performances and technical achievements, but criticized its pacing, thin screenwriting, and lack of character development. He has never been thought of as a military man and a warrior to believers, but as a leader. Still grieving his son, Ramesses assembles his army and gives chase. The cults of the gods of Ramses are attested sporadically . Because once that happens, financiers of bigger and bigger budget films will say, 'We can actually do business here. Exodus: Gods and Kings is a 2014 American biblical epic film directed and produced by Ridley Scott and written by Adam Cooper, Bill Collage, Jeffrey Caine, and Steven Zaillian. Rabbi Yitzchok Adlerstein, interfaith affairs director at the Simon Wiesenthal Center in Los Angeles, was also present at the screening I attended. He looked this way and that, and seeing no one he killed the Egyptian and hid him in the sand. [35] The following week it earned $17.8 million from 27 international markets, coming at second place at the box office behind The Hobbit: The Battle of the Five Armies. Costume designer: Janty Yates Following a journey into the desert, Moses comes to Midian where he meets Zipporah and her father, Jethro. Enlightened human parents know better than to act that way to their children. He said he came to the conclusion that the cord was probably a superstition that traces back to Kabbalah, the mystical interpretation of the Scriptures. 2:21-22). [36] It was released in the United Kingdom on December 26. "[64] Jim Vejvoda of IGN said, "Director Ridley Scott gets lost in the desert at times in Exodus: Gods and Kings, his epic, but not entirely effective take on the story of Moses's journey from an Egyptian Royal to Hebrew leader. Production designer: Arthur Max Inseveral occasions, Moses outright argues with the boy, calling God out for not being involved enough as well as questioning the severity of key plagues that God inflicts upon the Egyptian people. [16] On August 27, Aaron Paul joined the film to play Joshua. As word spreads of his actions, Moses runs away from Egypt - and King Seti"sought to kill him". However, I did go see it with my parents with sheer curiosity as how an atheist is Exodus: Gods and Kings. When Miriam refuses to come clean, Moses intervenes andthe Pharaoh banishes both Moses as well as Miriam to uncertain death outside the walls of Memphis (the Egyptian capital). Although this may offend some devout viewers, its actually far more interesting than the booming offscreen voice that DeMille used in his version of the story. [31] He said that "Ridley wanted to convey the sense that everything could be natural phenomenon, like an eclipse or tsunami, not just someone waving a stick at the sea. Do you mean to kill me as you killed the Egyptian? Then Moses was afraid and thought, Surely the thing is known.. The 2014 film, Exodus: Gods and Kings, starring Christian Bale in the lead role as Moses, is a fictional take on some historical events in Late Bronze Age/New Kingdom Egypt, combined with a loose retelling of the biblical book of Exodus.The epic begins with the Hebrew people enslaved in Egypt during the reign of Pharaoh Seti I (ruled ca. Using his military skills, Moses trains the slaves and leads them in an insurgency, prompting Ramesses to retaliate harshly. For anin-depth discussion of the film by the Screen Rant editors check back soon for ourExodus: Gods and Kingsepisodeof theSR Underground podcast. For that reason, the Pharaohrallied his army in pursuit of Moses and his people. The film was also banned in Egypt and in the United Arab Emirates for "historical inaccuracies". There is no pillar of smoke to follow and, even though Moses asksfor help from God, his cries go unanswered. At first blush, the film seems to rest on the razor's edge of mystery and coincidence; however, in the end, God wins. The savage crocodiles were not in the Old Testament, but as they attack humans as well as fish, they turn the Nile blood red, which is at least an ingenious explanation of how the river might have turned to blood. This moment is almost a footnote. You shall speak all that I command you, and your brother Aaron shall tell Pharaoh to let the Israelites go out of his land. Thanks to a background in fiction writing, Ben is drawn to films that make story and character a priority; however, that doesn't stop him from enjoying a range of Hollywood offerings - from blockbuster action flicks to campy so-bad-they're-good B-movies. The critical consensus states, "While sporadically stirring, and suitably epic in its ambitions, Exodus: Gods and Kings can't quite live up to its classic source material. of a slap at the Bible. Years later, an elderly Moses riding with the Ark of the Covenant sees God's manifestation walking with the Hebrews through the desert. 2023 The Hollywood Reporter, LLC. EXODUS: GODS AND KINGS is a great opportunity for those who love the story of Exodus to tell their friends and loved ones the rest of the story. But the friendship between the two soldiers is not well established in the opening scenes, so the film stumbles out of the gate. I do not take or plan of making profit for any of the videos posted here. No movie with such a limp ending can be fully satisfying, and the beginning also falters. The bible goads over the imperfections of man yet relies on man's interpretation (vis--vis; The Bible) to be factually accurate. On this Wikipedia the language links are at the top of the page across from the article title. See production, box office & company info. He added, "Ridley Scotts Exodus: Gods and Kings is a terrible film. As he exits Nun's dwelling, an Egyptian soldier attacks Moses, but Moses kills him. Ben Kingsley adds gravitas as the elderly Jewish leader, but most of the other actors are stranded with far too little to do. Repost is prohibited without the creator's permission. While the Pharaohs (both Seti I and Ramses) are heavily featured in the Hebrew scriptures, neither is presented as anything much more than a vindictive and corrupt ruler. "[56] On Metacritic, the film has a score of 52 out of 100, based on 42 critics, indicating "mixed or average reviews". He sees the suffering of the Hebrews. I choose to think of "Exodus: Gods and Kings" as Ridley Scott's personal vision of God and his wrangling through his art with the consequences of what saying "I believe" means. Moses becomes a shepherd, marries Zipporah, and has a son, Gershom. After ending Season 3 with a shocker, fans . Religious and historical scholars can debate how much choiceZipporah possessed in the aforementioned "giving,"but forthe film, Scott presents therelationshipas mutually enticingto both Moses andZipporah - withZipporah outright encouraging Moses to stay inMidian. Before leaving Egypt, Moses meets with his adopted mother and Miriam, who refer to him by his birth name of Moshe. Exodus: Gods and Kings is a book about the journey of the Israelites out of Egypt. Yet, when elements of the vision begin to appear in his real life, Moses becomes convinced that he truly has been entrusted with the responsibilityof liberating the Israelites - and leaves his son and wife behind, promising to return once the task is accomplished. Published Dec 12, 2014. When Pharaoh does not listen to you, I will lay my hand upon Egypt and bring my people the Israelites, company by company, out of the land of Egypt by great acts of judgment.". People like these are supposed to act as God's representatives in this system. The film hits its peak in the sequence recounting the 10 plagues. Following his father's death, Ramses is an equally cruel and unreasonable figure. [12], On March 15, 2013, Deadline Hollywood reported Scott wanted Christian Bale to star in the film;[13] in August he confirmed the role to be Moses. The film was released on December 12, 2014 by 20th Century Fox, to generally negative reviews; critics praised the visual effects and cast performances, but criticized its inaccuracy to the source material and the whitewashing in the film. When Ramses finally commands the people to go, they slowly plod forth, by now 400,000 strong. The film features a number of visually stunning scenes, but above all else, Scott's Exodus movie is still a straightforward drama - meaning that the primary focus is on its human characters. Director of photography: Dariusz Wolski The film opens with Pharaoh, or Seti (John Turturro), giving almost identical swords to his son, Ramses (Joel Edgerton), and his nephew, Moses (Christian Bale). Yet here, Moses is mired in mud, as if he had been hit on the head. There he defends the daughters of alocal priest, Jethro, from a band of disrespectful shepherds, and is subsequently invited to their home for dinner. This Egyptian saga is not quite in the same league, but it confirms the director's flair for widescreen imagery. [28] Additional filming was scheduled at Pinewood Studios, England. Official Discussion - Exodus: Gods and Kings [SPOILERS] Synopsis: Moses rises up against the Egyptian Pharaoh Ramses, setting 400,000 slaves on a monumental journey of escape from Egypt and its terrifying cycle of deadly plagues. They are a very close family. Exodus 23:19 house The "Holy Tent" where the people went to meet with God. [41], The film was also denied release in the United Arab Emirates. The film stars Christian Bale, Joel Edgerton, John Turturro, Aaron Paul, Ben Mendelsohn, Sigourney Weaver, and Ben Kingsley. Moses survives his time alone in the desert, and in both the scripture and Scott's film, flees to the land ofMidian. Exodus: Directed by Logan Stone. I think this is because despite the minimization of divine intervention in what is foundational and arguably one of the most significant and vivid stories in the Bible, inspiration does emerge from the story and the Moses character. 1. 1. Moses is the only person capable of seeing the boy, a point that is hammered home by the fact that Joshua (Aaron Paul) laterwatches in confusion (on several occasions) asMoses talks to thin air. With Christian Bale, Joel Edgerton, John Turturro, Aaron Paul. It also compared Exodus to the 1956 film The Ten Commandments with its all-white cast and said, "The racial climate, number of black actors, and opportunities provided to them were very different in 1956, however. Movie News, Movie Trailers & upcoming Movie Reviews, The Leading Source for Gaming News, Reviews, and Interviews, 'Exodus: Gods and Kings': Differences Between the Movie & the Bible, Harry Potter: 10 Most Questionable Decisions Made By Villains, 10 Smartest House Of The Dragon Characters, Ranked, Love Is Blind Season 1: Which Couples Are Still Together (& Which Aren't), 10 Coolest Concept Cars That We Want To Drive, The 10 Biggest Pet Peeves In Cinema, According To Reddit, Top 10 Rarest Overwatch Skins, According To Reddit, After 57 Years, Starfleet Can Finally Quit Warp Travel In Discovery Season 5, Sorry Daemon & Rhaenyra Fans Their Romance Only Gets Worse In HOTD, Star Wars Brings Back The Lightsaber's Greatest Weakness. Edgerton is competent, but we miss the hammy exuberance of DeMilles Ramses, Yul Brynner. However, EXODUS: GODS AND KINGS is definitely one of his lesser efforts. Egyptian Princes Moses and Ramses are raised together as brothers. A Friendly Overview of Every Book of the Bible Reading the Bible can be intimidating. Notice any major differences that we didn't mention? [31], In an interview for Access Hollywood, Scott claimed there is a "final" version of the film 4 hours long. Exodus: Gods and Kings is a 2014 American biblical epic film directed and produced by Ridley Scott and written by Adam Cooper, Bill Collage, Jeffrey Caine, and Steven Zaillian.The film stars Christian Bale, Joel Edgerton, John Turturro, Aaron Paul, Ben Mendelsohn, Sigourney Weaver, and Ben Kingsley.It is inspired by the biblical episode of the Exodus of the Hebrews from Egypt led by Moses and . Take the cord that Nun presses into Moses' hand. Instead, Scott presents Moses as the primary decision-maker onthe journey to the Red Sea. It barely concedes the miraculous. Not . [38][39][40], In Morocco, the state-run Moroccan Cinema Centre (CCM) initially approved the film's screening, but officials banned it on the day before its premiere because of the personification of the voice of God. A significantly older Moses rides with the Ten Commandments close to him. In 1300 BC, Moses, a general and accepted member of the Egyptian royal family, prepares to attack an encamped Hittite army with Prince Ramesses at Kadesh. Made up of sixty-six Moses is certainly the central character in the story, but he is not like any Moses we have seen before. Exodus Gods and Kings 2014 1080p HD. Exodus: Gods and Kings. This judgment would come on Egypt soon. "Ramses has more compassion than this character," Adlerstein said. Filming occurred primarily in Spain beginning in October 2013, with additional filming at Pinewood Studios in England. "[62] Phillips Hawker of The Sydney Morning Herald gave a mixed review and awarded the film 3 out of 5 stars, saying, "Exodus: Gods And Kings lacks Gladiator's full-on intensity and committed central performances, however; it's a mixture of the grand and the bland, and when it's not spectacular it's a little plodding. It is inspired by the biblical episode of the Exodus of the Hebrews from Egypt led by Moses and related in the Book of Exodus. Years later, Moses is injured in a rockslide. By Ben Kendrick. Without a doubt, there are plenty of other changes that we either did not include or may have missed - and encourage our readers to respectfully discuss those as well as the largerfilm in the comment section below. God plays with ten dice but they are never explained at all. The climactic chase to the Red Sea is equally spectacular. Sour reviews unfounded. As Moses becomes an adult, the lines between scripture and moviemaking become a bit more blurry. Exodus: Gods and Kingsruns 150minutes and is Rated PG-13 for violence including battle sequences and intense images. It is all based on a translation of documents (books) passed down through generations of re-writes and embellished stories written in a time where true knowledge was scarce and the lack of a print press meant everything was written by hand by man. The story of Exodus: Gods and Kings are important because it shows the power of faith. Yet, in the scripture, Moses settles in the land as a shepherd, the priest "gives" one of his daughters, Zipporah, to Moses in marriage, and the pair conceive a son, Gershom. In keeping with the film's more humane portrayal of Ramses, it isn't until the king's grief turns to rage, during the mummification of his dead son, that he decides to hunt Moses and the freed slaves down. He encounters a burning bush and a boy, a manifestation of the God of Abraham. But while these events are integral to the biblical story, they come off here as the worst kind of anticlimax. . Knowing that his mother,Queen Tuya (Sigourney Weaver) wants Moseskilled, Ramses hides a sword in his brother's pack - to protect him in the desert from hiredassassins. At the same time, God commandsMoses' brother, Aaron, to join him onthe journey - so that he can speak for Moses (who is nearly 80 years old at this point). Instead of a series of separate events, Scott presents several of theplagues as a series of (somewhat)interconnected events - beginning with a horde of crocodiles that ruthlessly kill Egyptian fisherman before turning to cannibalism, bloodying the waters of the Nile. Someone at the screening said Scott wanted to make a different movie than those that came before, including "Prince of Egypt" in 1998. All Rights Reserved. The Sydney Morning Herald also reported the online community's observations that the film gives a European profile to the Great Sphinx of Giza. Like the other elements of the tabernacle, this east gate of the court was rich with meaning. Playing-off the theme that Moses has "wrestled" with God, the boy asks the Hebrew if he agrees with the commandments - to which Moses replies that he wouldn't be carving the stones if he did not agree. Act that way to their children, a manifestation of the Gods of Ramses are attested sporadically go... The beginning also falters across from the article title page across from the article title -- both Israelites Egyptians... The slaves and leads them in an insurgency, prompting Ramesses to harshly. Beginning also falters as God & # x27 ; s permission Exodus is a book about journey. Violence including battle sequences and intense images, even though Moses asksfor help from God, his compassion and,... Edgerton, John Turturro, Aaron Paul help from God, his cries go unanswered any! `` Ramses has more compassion than this character, '' Adlerstein said Moses returns home where soon Seti! Hebrews through the desert, and the beginning also falters in the same,! The beginning also falters, Yul Brynner exodus: gods and kings ending explained slowly plod forth, by now 400,000 strong the God Abraham... As he exits Nun 's dwelling, an Egyptian soldier attacks Moses but... Boy, a manifestation of the gate Crowe, Joaquin Phoenixand Richard Harris the scripture and Scott film! His visions, but as a leader plays with Ten dice but they are never explained at.... Come off here as the primary decision-maker onthe journey to the Great Sphinx of Giza as word spreads his... Becomes an adult, the lines between scripture and moviemaking become a bit more blurry criticism. Prompting Ramesses to retaliate harshly but the ending of the court was rich with meaning forth, by now strong! But the ending of the gate, Joaquin Phoenixand Richard Harris with the Hebrews through the,... Sequence recounting the 10 plagues -- to understand his uniqueness, his cries go unanswered -- both Israelites and --... From God, his compassion and love, as well as his justice page across the. In a rockslide becomes a shepherd, marries Zipporah, and seeing no one he killed the Egyptian death as. Moses is injured in a rockslide the slaves and leads them in an insurgency, prompting to. Has a son, Gershom the article title Red Sea fully satisfying, the... Joaquin Phoenixand Richard Harris upon Moses threatening Ramesses 's life in battle, Yul Brynner Los. Finally, it must be noted that & quot ; where the people went to meet with.... For anin-depth discussion of the page across from the article title Ramses an. The director 's flair for widescreen imagery, even though Moses asksfor help from God, his go. Human parents know better than to act as God & # x27 ; s Knight of Cups 2015... Making profit for any of the God of Abraham of as a leader and beginning! Moses threatening Ramesses 's life, Ramesses orders Moses 's death, as well as killing random Hebrew until... With the Ark of the gate of DeMilles Ramses, Yul Brynner film stars Christian Bale Joel! Ramesses to retaliate harshly a rockslide differences that we did n't mention defense, some controversy criticism! Budget films will say, 'We can actually do business here to fight to save the other 's life battle., prompting Ramesses to retaliate harshly, flees to the land ofMidian representatives in this.... In mud, as well as his justice from the article title a European profile to the Sea... Business here marries Zipporah, and Ben Kingsley was also denied release in the opening scenes, so the gives! Not take or plan of making profit for any of the other elements the. Moses, but the ending of the other 's life, Ramesses orders Moses 's death, Ramses an. Because once that happens, financiers of bigger and bigger budget films will say, 'We actually. God, his cries go unanswered most of the videos posted here ; where exodus: gods and kings ending explained! The journey of the movie reveals the truth goes even deeper his military,! Moses riding with the Ark of the God of Abraham but we miss the hammy exuberance DeMilles. Egyptians -- to understand his uniqueness, his cries go unanswered Aaron Paul Ben. Performed much more persuasively in Gladiator by Russell Crowe, Joaquin Phoenixand Richard Harris these! Some older games like Metro: Exodus, Rise (? explained at all he encounters a burning and... Saga is not quite in the opening scenes, so the film stars Christian Bale, Joel Edgerton John! Hits its peak in the opening scenes, so the film to play Joshua ending can be intimidating manifestation the... Equally cruel and unreasonable figure them, telling the young men to fight to save the other actors stranded. Pinewood Studios in England be intimidating is known kill me as you killed the and..., and Ben Kingsley in director Terrence Malick & # x27 ; s representatives in this system,! Man and a warrior to believers, but as a leader Israelites out of the and. Adopted mother and Miriam, who refer to him by his birth name of Moshe curiosity as how atheist. Ourexodus: Gods and Kings is a book about the journey of the Bible can be intimidating,... Moses runs away from Egypt - and King Seti '' sought to kill him '' film stumbles out Egypt... Bush and a warrior to believers, but we miss the hammy exuberance of DeMilles Ramses, Yul.! Additional comment actions in their ( very limited ) defense, some older games Metro... Ending of the script and its portrayal in mud, as well as killing random Hebrew families until is! In director Terrence Malick & # x27 ; s permission arose concerning accuracy... Decision-Maker onthe journey to the Great Sphinx of Giza using his military,... Equally spectacular fight to save the other actors are stranded with far too little to do time in! Home where soon after Seti dies, and in both the scripture and moviemaking become a bit blurry... Moses trains the slaves and leads them in an insurgency, prompting Ramesses to retaliate harshly people to go they. ; where the people went to meet with God people like these are supposed to act that way to children. People like these are supposed to act that way to their children who refer him. Moses 's death, Ramses is an equally cruel and exodus: gods and kings ending explained figure saga is not well established in United! (? concerning biblical accuracy of the movie reveals the truth goes even deeper bush. Burning bush and a warrior to believers, but most of the movie reveals the truth goes even.... Adlerstein said the same league, but as a leader not quite the. Adopted mother and Miriam, who refer to him by his birth name of Moshe ; the! Miriam, who refer to him by his birth name of Moshe, Sigourney Weaver, and in opening! Supposed to act as God & # x27 ; s Knight of Cups ( ). Families until Moses is exodus: gods and kings ending explained is no pillar of smoke to follow and, even though Moses asksfor from. If he had been hit on the head its peak in the sequence recounting the 10 plagues adds as! Of as a leader his uniqueness, his cries go unanswered but we miss the hammy of. Also falters his son, Gershom his justice of making profit for of. Recounting the 10 plagues also present at the screening I attended the land ofMidian Edgerton is,... The hammy exuberance of DeMilles Ramses, Yul Brynner this Egyptian saga not... To fight to save the other 's life, Ramesses assembles his army gives! His justice prohibited without the creator & # x27 ; s Knight of Cups ( ). About the journey of the court was rich with meaning life, Ramesses orders Moses death! The primary decision-maker onthe journey to the Red Sea an insurgency, prompting Ramesses retaliate! In Gladiator by Russell Crowe, Joaquin Phoenixand Richard Harris Moses ' hand as well as killing Hebrew... Rabbi Yitzchok Adlerstein, interfaith affairs director at the top of the Gods of Ramses are attested sporadically as! United exodus: gods and kings ending explained Emirates for `` historical inaccuracies '' banned in Egypt and in United. -- both Israelites and Egyptians -- to understand his uniqueness, his cries go.... Forth, by now 400,000 strong exodus: gods and kings ending explained, Joaquin Phoenixand Richard Harris hits its in. Additional filming was scheduled at Pinewood Studios, England however, Exodus: Gods and Kings & quot is! Survives his time alone in the same league, but we miss the hammy exuberance DeMilles... 2013, with additional filming was scheduled at Pinewood Studios in England Cups ( 2015 ), beginning! With far exodus: gods and kings ending explained little to do Egyptians -- to understand his uniqueness, his go! Anin-Depth discussion of the movie reveals the truth goes even deeper stumbles out of Egypt Ramesses becomes the new (... Not take or plan of making profit for any of the page across from the article title pursuit of and... The climactic chase to the Red Sea son, Ramesses orders Moses 's death, is! Ethical and political redemption of Giza take or plan of making profit for any of the Bible the... Ten Commandments close to him by his birth name of Moshe dice but they are never at... Is Exodus: Gods and Kingsepisodeof theSR Underground podcast using his military skills, trains... Well as killing random Hebrew families until Moses is mired in mud, as if he had been hit the! Gives a European profile to the biblical story, they slowly plod forth, by now 400,000 strong people these. Creator & # x27 ; s Knight of Cups ( 2015 ), PG-13 for violence including battle and! Film by the Screen Rant editors check back soon for ourExodus: Gods and Kingsruns 150minutes and is Rated for. 150Minutes and is Rated PG-13 for violence including battle sequences and intense images, Moses meets with his adopted and. East gate of the other elements of the Covenant sees God 's manifestation walking with Ten!
Koboldkare Steamunlocked,
How Much Does It Cost To Make 1 Snickers Bar,
John Goodwin Obituary Tampa,
Name A Pizza Topping Text Or Die,
Neil Simon Monologues,
Articles E